Title
Section 3: Evaluation of Image Capture CardsIntroductionPick up virtually any PC computer magazine and you will be presented with a bewildering choice of cards offering combined facilities such as video capture and playback, enhanced graphic display capabilities, windows acceleration, TV tuning, and amongst other things, still image capture. This, coupled with the development of other bus architectures, PCI (Peripheral Component Interconnect) and VL (Video/Vesa Local), has led to some confusion for the teacher who simply wants to purchase a card for still image capture.This section takes a look at a number of cards available for still image capture including the more traditional cards and those where still image capture is one of a number of options offered. There is a concern that the quality of images obtained with the newer, cheaper, multifunctional cards will be inferior to that from the 'standard' image capture cards, many of which will shortly be no longer available. The cards evaluated are primarily for the PC, as the majority of academic institutions support the PC platform for delivering electronic teaching and learning materials. However, Apple MAC options are detailed where appropriate and the evaluation includes one image capture card for the Apple MAC. Bus Architecture; ISA vs PCI vs VLThe ISA (Industries Standard Architecture) Bus (also known as the AT bus) is found in any AT type computer. However the data transfer rate across the ISA bus is limited and is restrictive for applications needing high data transfer rates such as those involving moving video. The PCI bus not only provides greater bandwidth but is also processor independent. This is probably one of the PCI bus' greatest assets and because of this is likely to become the future standard for bus architecture. Thus any PCI card can be installed into any PCI based computer whether a PC, PowerMac, DEC, Alpha, etc. At the moment the data bus width of the PCI bus is 32 bits and as long as appropriate drivers are available will probably be developed further to support 64 bits. The VL bus, while offering higher bandwidth, is unfortunately a PC dependent architecture and is therefore less likely to develop much further.At the time of writing few PCI cards are available supporting still image capture. This situation is likely to change rapidly. Vesa Media ChannelThe Vesa Media Channel (easily confused with the VL bus) is a feature built into cards that is independent of bus architecture and can therefore be found on ISA, PCI or VL cards. Vesa Media Channel allows one to link (daisy chain) up to 15 cards together, thus allowing any limitation in bus speeds to be bypassed or enabling the cards to run in parallel with the bus effectively maximising bandwidth.AimsTo evaluate a number of still image capture cards in order to provide recommendations and guidelines on purchase to the academic community.MethodA number of cards (11 in total) were evaluated. For each card, details including appearance, connectors, installation of hardware and software, capture times and other observations are given. The default settings given for each card for brightness, contrast and colour were used. The cards and any associated software were assessed using the same set of images in each case. The quality of the captured images was compared against a group reference.The cards can be divided into two categories:
|